PublicSquare

Upfront Cost Calculator: Rent-to-Own vs a Mortgage

How much do you need in the bank before you can move into a home? Put a price in and compare what a mortgage asks for on day one — deposit, stamp duty, lenders mortgage insurance — with what Rent-to-Own asks for.

Before you move in

How much cheaper is Rent to Own, upfront?
9.5x cheaper
Rent to Own
$4,200
  • Upfront deposit$0
  • Engagement fee$1,100
  • Setup fee (new home)$0
  • Legal advice$1,100
  • Rental bond$2,000
  • Stamp dutyLater, at buyout
Mortgage
$40,100
  • Deposit (5%)$37,500
  • Stamp duty (QLD, FHB)$0
  • LMI$0 — scheme
  • Conveyancing$2,000
  • Building & pest$600

Plus the first two weeks of payments — about $1,947. Two weeks of rent and deposit contributions are payable upfront before you move in, the same as a standard tenancy. It is not included in the Rent to Own total above.

Assumptions

Mortgage side: deposit at the chosen percentage, transfer (stamp) duty at owner-occupier rates with any first-home concession you tick, Lenders Mortgage Insurance on the 10% path (indicative premium), plus $2,000 conveyancing and $600 building and pest inspections. The 5% path assumes a place under the First Home Guarantee, which removes LMI but not the other costs — property price caps apply. Choosing it ticks the first-home toggle automatically, since the scheme is for first home buyers; untick it if you're using the scheme as a returning buyer (no ownership in the past 10 years), because duty concessions require never having owned a home. Rent to Own side, per PublicSquare's published pricing: engagement fee $1,100 (refundable if the acquisition doesn't reach unconditional), independent legal advice $1,100, fixed rental bond $2,000, and a setup fee of 0.99% of the initial home value for an established home — 0% for a new home from the building panel. The first two weeks of rent and deposit contributions are also payable before you move in; they are shown separately and are not part of the Rent to Own total or the cheaper-upfront multiple. Indicative rent is 4.5% of the home value a year, with the contribution fixed at 50% of it. Stamp duty on a Rent to Own home is payable when you buy, years later, and first-home concessions may apply then. Moving costs apply on either path and are excluded.

General information only — not financial, credit, legal, or tax advice. Results are estimates based on the stated assumptions and your inputs; obtain independent professional advice before making any decision. When you buy your Rent to Own home, the deposit, stamp duty, LMI and other standard purchasing costs become payable where applicable — these costs are deferred, not waived. Cheaper-upfront multiples compare total day-one cash for a mortgage purchase (deposit, stamp duty, any LMI, conveyancing and inspections) with Rent to Own starting costs. Averaged across home prices of $500,000–$1,000,000, deposit paths from 5% (no-LMI scheme) to 20%, and new and established homes at Queensland owner-occupier duty rates with no first-home concessions, Rent to Own is on average ~18x cheaper upfront.

How to read the result

The big number is the gap between the two. It is not money you save — stamp duty and a deposit are still ahead of you under Rent-to-Own, paid when you buy in years four to eight — but it is money you do not need to have now. Try the 5% deposit setting to see the mortgage route at its cheapest: the deposit is smaller, but lenders mortgage insurance appears.

What the calculator assumes

  • Stamp duty is calculated at each state's owner-occupier rates, with first-home buyer concessions applied when you tick that option.
  • Lenders mortgage insurance is estimated at 4.2% of the loan on a 5% deposit, 1.9% on 10%, 0.9% on 15% and nil at 20%. Real premiums vary by lender.
  • Mortgage route: $2,000 conveyancing and $600 building and pest.
  • Rent-to-Own route: $1,100 engagement fee (refundable if the acquisition does not reach unconditional), $1,100 independent legal advice, $2,000 rental bond, and a setup fee of 0.99% of the initial home value on an established home (nil on a new home from the building panel).
  • The program's initial home value is between $500,000 and $1,000,000.

Frequently asked questions

Yes, but later. Stamp duty is paid when you buy the home, in the purchase window between years four and eight, at the rates and concessions that apply then.

Written by

Dean Arnold
Dean Arnold

Founder & CEO

Licensed real estate agent

I started PublicSquare in 2021 to give homebuyers a real path to ownership without a deposit, and investors a stronger-cashflow alternative to a standard rental. I hold real estate licences in Queensland and New South Wales and personally review every property that enters the program.

Reviewed by

Jarrod Wills
Jarrod Wills

Property Lead

Licensed agent · Former mortgage broker

I was a mortgage broker before joining PublicSquare, so I look at every property and every purchase the way a lender would. I now lead the property side of the program, helping homebuyers from their first info session through to move-in, and working with our buyers agency team on each acquisition for our investors.

Read more about Rent-to-Own.

This article is general information only and does not take your personal circumstances into account. PublicSquare is a licensed real estate agency, not a financial adviser or credit provider. Consider seeking independent advice before making a decision.